Ice Cream Pie Recipe – How To Make This Easy, Elegant Party Dessert

Foods & DrinksCooking Tips & Recipes

  • Author Linda Kling
  • Published August 21, 2011
  • Word count 743

Are you looking for an easy, showstopping, summer dessert recipe that’s impressive enough for a party? Here’s how to make an ice cream pie, including directions for a cookie crust (with variations), plus ideas for fillings and toppings. Everyone will love it!

For the very basic recipe:

1 cookie crust (store-bought or made from scratch – recipe follows)

1 tub ice cream (1 quart – 1/2 gallon)


Soften the ice cream, until it’s just soft enough to scoop out easily, then put into prepared pie shell. Smooth out the top. Cover lightly. Freeze until firm, at least two hours or overnight. Remove from freezer 15 minutes before serving. Then garnish with desired toppings (whipped cream, chocolate or caramel sauce, magic shell, crushed cookies, fresh fruit, etc.

Of course, you could just buy a pie shell and fill it with ice cream and it would be a nice dessert. But if you want to impress your guests, then you can make a delicious cookie crust from scratch and fill your pie shell with interesting flavor combinations, mix-ins and toppings.


1 1/2 cups fine crumbs (from graham crackers, ginger snaps, vanilla wafers, chocolate cookies, shortbread – any crisp cookie, store-bought or homemade)

1/4 cup granulated sugar

6 tablespoons butter, melted

Crush crumbs in a food processor or the old fashioned way – in a large, heavy-duty resealable bag. (Leave a small opening in the top of the bag to allow air to escape.) Roll a rolling pin over the plastic bag until the cookies are broken into crumbs.

Mix crumbs and sugar together, stir in melted butter. Line pie plate with mixture, pressing firmly into place. Bake at 350 degrees for 8 minutes. Cool thoroughly before adding ice cream.


2 cups crushed (very fine) pretzels

1/2 cup melted butter

1/3 cup sugar

Combine all crust ingredients. Press crumbs over bottom and up sides of 9-inch pie plate. Bake for 8-10 minutes. Cool completely.


13 Oreo cookies, crushed

1/4 cup butter (1/2 stick), melted

Mix Oreos and butter together and firmly press into a 9-inch pie pan over the bottom and all the way up the sides. Chill for 20 minutes to set.

Now, for the fun part. Get creative and come up with some combinations for some truly spectacular desserts:

  • ICE CREAM MUD PIE – Oreo crust, coffee ice cream, topped with thick chocolate syrup

  • PEACH MELBA ICE CREAM PIE – Nilla wafer crust, peach ice cream, topped with raspberry sauce, garnished with fresh peaches

  • BANANA-SPLIT ICE CREAM PIE – Chocolate cookie crust, layer of thinly sliced bananas, followed by strawberry ice cream, freeze – before serving, top with drained crushed pineapple, whipped cream and maraschino cherries.

  • SNICKERS ICE CREAM PIE – Make chocolate cookie crust, adding 1/4 cup peanuts to the recipe. Mix into soften vanilla ice cream – 6 (2 oz) coarsely chopped Snickers bars. Spread mixture in pie shell, freeze. Before serving, drizzle with chocolate and caramel sauce and additonal chopped snickers bars to top.

  • LEMONADE ICE CREAM PIE – Mix 1/2 gallon softened vanilla ice cream with a 12-oz can lemonade or limeade, slightly thawed and spread in a pretzel crust.

  • PEANUT BUTTER ICE CREAM PIE – Mix 1/2 gallon softened vanilla ice cream with 1 cup peanut butter (smooth or chunky) until combined. Swirl in peanut butter chips, fudge chunks and fudge ice cream topping. Spread mixture in chocolate cookie pie shell. When ready to serve, top with chocolate magic shell.

  • PUMPKIN ICE CREAM PIE – Mix 1/2 gallon softened vanilla ice cream with 1 cup canned pumpkin, 1/2 cup packed brown sugar, 1 teaspoon ground ginger, 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon and 1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg. Spread in a gingersnap cookie crust. Freeze until firm. Garnish with whipped cream.

  • LAYERED ICE CREAM PIE – Spread 3 cups of any flavor ice cream in prepared pie shell, top with crushed candy, cookie crumbs or ice cream sauce – freeze for 30 minutes. Remove from freezer, spread 3 cups of a different flavor ice cream on top. Refreeze 2 hours – overnight. Some ideas: orange sorbet and vanilla ice cream layers for a creamsicle ice cream pie; or layers of chocolate and coffee ice cream for a mocha ice cream pie. How about chocolate ice cream layered with cherry vanilla ice cream for a chocolate-cherry ice cream pie (garnish with chocolate covered cherries).

With your imagination, you can make your own signature version of this ice cream pie. Use your favorite cookies (for the crust), ice cream flavors, mix-ins and toppings to put together this super-easy dessert. It’s sure to be the hit of any party!

Linda Kling, as the owner of, has offered ideas to people planning parties since 1992. Visit her website for more information on unique party favors, plus free printables, party recipes, quotes, trivia, more. Follow Photo Party Favors on Facebook at for even more free party stuff, including the cupcake recipe of the month.

Article source:

This article has been viewed 1,462 times.